Outbound sales for chargeback and fraud prevention companies

Outbound Sales for Chargeback and Fraud Prevention Companies

If you're running a chargeback or fraud prevention platform, you already know that procurement moves slowly. Your prospects—merchants, acquiring banks, payment processors—they're not hunting for your solution on Google. They're buried in operational work, dealing with the fallout from fraud incidents and chargebacks, but they haven't allocated budget for a new vendor yet.

Cold outreach is where most fraud and chargeback companies stumble. They either don't do it at all, or they do it the wrong way. Generic emails about "risk management" don't move the needle with CFOs and VP Finance teams. You need a system that accounts for how these buyers actually make decisions.

The Challenge: Why Standard Outbound Fails Here

Chargeback and fraud prevention plays in a weird market gap. Your product solves urgent, real problems—but the buying committee doesn't think about it until they've already lost significant money. Even then, procurement cycles run 4-6 months.

The standard playbook fails because:

• Deal velocity is slow. We're talking 90+ day sales cycles minimum. Most teams kill outbound efforts after 30 days of silence.

• Multi-threaded selling is mandatory. You need CFO buy-in, operations buy-in, legal/compliance. One email to one person gets you nowhere.

• Vertical specificity matters heavily. A card processor cares about different metrics than a marketplace or BNPL platform. Generic outreach feels lazy.

• Trust is the actual product. These companies are paranoid about vendor lock-in, data breaches, and implementation risk. You're asking them to route fraud detection through your system.

The Outbound System That Works

Here's what actually converts for this vertical:

1. Segment by Buyer Archetype, Not Just Company Size

Don't just target "companies with 200+ employees." Segment by:

• Card processors and ISO networks (different value prop than merchants)

• Acquiring banks (regulatory pressure is the key driver)

• Marketplaces and platforms (network risk, seller liability)

• Standalone merchants (cash flow impact is immediate)

Each one has different KPIs you should reference in your outreach. A marketplace cares about seller trust and chargeback rates. An acquiring bank cares about capital reserves and regulatory reporting. Reference their specific world.

2. Thread the Deal From Day One

Single-threaded outreach converts at roughly 2-3% in this space. Multi-threaded (3+ stakeholders) converts at 8-12%.

Start with operations or VP of Risk, but immediately establish a secondary thread with Finance. Here's why: operations cares about operational burden and chargeback velocity. Finance cares about cash impact and reserve requirements. Both need to agree, and you need both conversations happening in parallel.

3. Lead with Specific Loss Data, Not Product Features

Don't open with: "We prevent fraud with ML-powered detection."

Open with: "I noticed you're processing ~$40M annually in transaction volume. At typical chargeback rates for your vertical, that's probably running $180K-$240K in annual losses. We typically recover 35-45% of that in the first 6 months."

Specific numbers land differently. They show you've done research. They let the buyer do math in their head about ROI.

4. Reference Time-to-Value, Not Time-to-Deployment

Implementation is a real objection here. Your product probably takes 60-90 days to fully integrate. Don't hide that.

Instead, lead with: "We go live with baseline protection in 14 days, then optimize rules over the next 60." That's a real timeline they can work with. Early wins build internal momentum for deeper implementation.

5. Use Call-First Approach With Email Sequences

Connect rates on cold calls to CFO/VP Finance in this vertical run 18-25% if you're hitting the right person at the right time. Email-first doesn't work. Phone-first does.

Your sequence should be: phone call (live), voicemail + same-day email, email sequence (3 more), then swing back to phone. This cadence respects their inbox without disappearing.

6. Create Vertical-Specific Case Studies

Generic case studies don't move the dial. Create one for each segment:

• For processors: "How a $15B payment processor reduced chargeback reserve requirements by 8%"

• For marketplaces: "How a p2p marketplace reduced seller chargebacks by 42% in 90 days"

• For standalone merchants: "How a DTC brand recovered $180K in annual chargeback losses"

Make metrics specific. Make timelines realistic. Make it about their archetype, not your best customer.

The Metrics That Matter

Track these religiously:

• Conversations scheduled (not emails sent)

• Stakeholder count per deal (aim for 3+)

• Time to first conversation (speed matters; weeks-old data is stale)

• Conversation-to-proposal rate (should run 25-35%)

• Deal cycle length (your benchmark)

Most fraud/chargeback companies are in 90-120 day deal cycles. If your outbound is generating conversations but they're stalling at 60 days, your value prop isn't resonating or you don't have enough stakeholders engaged.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Persistence that becomes harassment. In fraud prevention, everyone's paranoid about vendors. Too many touches and you're marked as spam. Stick to 5-7 touchpoints over 30 days, then break.

Treating all contacts the same. The ops person and the CFO need completely different messaging. Don't send the same email sequence to both.

Missing the regulatory angle. Compliance and regulatory pressure is often the actual trigger for budget. If you're not connecting your solution to compliance wins (SOC 2, PCI DSS, specific regulatory requirements), you're leaving money on the table.

Skipping proof of execution. Case studies matter less than documented implementation timelines and success metrics from similar companies in their vertical.

---

Work With a Team That Understands This Space

Running outbound for chargeback and fraud prevention companies requires a team that knows fintech sales. You need people who can speak credibly about reserve requirements, regulatory pressure, and implementation timelines. You need call teams that can thread multiple stakeholders and follow a 90+ day deal cycle without losing momentum.

We run this exact playbook for fintech and insurtech companies through Glencoco, our pay-per-meeting model. Your team books qualified conversations with CFOs, VP Finance, and VP Risk in your target verticals. No retainer. No long-term commitment. You pay for meetings that hit your ICP and advance your deal cycle.

If you're ready to build a real outbound motion for fraud prevention or chargeback companies, let's talk. [Schedule time with us](https://cal.com/nurturance) to walk through your vertical, your current pipeline, and what a structured outbound program could look like.