How to build an ICP for fintech outbound campaigns

Why Your Fintech Outreach is Failing (It's Probably Your ICP)

We run cold calling campaigns for fintech companies, and the pattern is always the same. Teams that struggle aren't struggling because of bad dialers or weak scripts. They're struggling because they're chasing the wrong prospects.

An Ideal Customer Profile (ICP) isn't a nice-to-have document. It's the foundation of every dollar you spend on outreach. Without one, you're sending your team to call people who can't say yes, no matter how good your pitch is.

At Nurturance, we've built ICPs for payment processors, lending platforms, crypto exchanges, and insurance tech companies. The ones that move the needle share a few distinct characteristics. This is what we've learned.

What an ICP Actually Is (and Isn't)

Your ICP is a detailed description of the company and decision-maker most likely to buy your product, based on data, not assumptions.

It's not:

• A wish list of ideal customers

• A description of your current biggest clients

• A generic "mid-market B2B company"

It's a profile built from your actual closed deals, your low-effort conversations, and your highest customer lifetime value customers.

Too many fintech teams build ICPs around revenue size alone. That's the trap. A $50M fintech company might be a terrible fit. A $10M company in the right vertical with the right pain point might close in three conversations.

Step 1: Analyze Your Wins (This is Non-Negotiable)

Pull your last 20-30 closed deals or qualified opportunities. For each one, document:

• Company size (ARR, not headcount)

• Industry and vertical (is this a B2B lending platform serving SMBs or enterprises?)

• Geography (US, EU, APAC, or focused?)

• Decision-maker title (founder, CFO, VP of Operations, Head of Growth)

• The core problem they had (compliance reporting, customer acquisition, risk management)

• Time to close (how many touches before a meeting)

• Contract value and expansion potential

You'll start seeing patterns immediately. Maybe 60% of your wins are fintech companies doing B2B lending with under $20M ARR. Maybe your best customers are all in the UK or Singapore.

This isn't about being inclusive. It's about being efficient.

Step 2: Define Company Characteristics

Once you see the pattern, write down the company-level criteria:

• Revenue range: Most of our clients see cleanest results in the $5M-$50M ARR band for fintech. Below $5M, founders are overloaded and meetings are hard. Above $50M, committees slow everything down.

• Stage: Series A, B, or growth-stage companies usually have the budget and the urgency. Pre-product companies are too early. Late-stage companies already have entrenched solutions.

• Vertical specificity: "Fintech" is too broad. Get specific. Are you targeting payments, lending, insurance, crypto, embedded finance, or something else?

• Geography: Cold calling is better when you can match timezone. If you're calling UK companies from the US, expect half the connection rate.

Write this down in concrete terms, not marketing speak. Don't write "high-growth fintech." Write "Series B or C payment infrastructure companies, $10M-$40M ARR, founded in the last 5 years."

Step 3: Profile Your Decision-Makers

This is where most outreach teams fall apart.

Call the wrong person, and you'll get nowhere. Call the right person, and you'll get a meeting.

For fintech, your ICP decision-maker depends on what you're selling:

• Selling compliance or regulatory software? You're calling the Chief Compliance Officer or Head of Legal. Not the CTO.

• Selling customer acquisition tools? You're calling the Chief Growth Officer or VP of Marketing. Not the CFO.

• Selling internal operations or payments infrastructure? You're calling the VP of Engineering or Chief Product Officer.

Find the actual buyer, not the person who uses your product.

Document:

• Primary title (and 2-3 alternate titles that work)

• Experience level (have they been in the role for 2+ years?)

• Typical background (did they come from operations, engineering, or product?)

For example: "VP of Operations with 3+ years experience, typically came from fintech or fast-growing B2B SaaS, reports to the COO or CEO, responsible for company-wide process efficiency and compliance."

That's specific. That moves your needle.

Step 4: Research Intent and Pain Points

This separates expensive outreach from cheap outreach.

Look at your best customers. Why did they take your call? What was happening in their business?

Were they:

• Raising a funding round (they have money and problems to solve)

• Launching a new product line (they need tools fast)

• Expanding to a new market (compliance, infrastructure, customer acquisition all matter more)

• Losing customers to a competitor (they're hunting for solutions)

Document leading indicators of high intent. Then, when you build your prospect list, you can filter for these signals.

For fintech, we target companies that are:

• Hiring aggressively in the last 3-6 months

• Announcing new feature launches or product expansions

• Raising capital

• Expanding to new geographies

These are proxies for urgency.

Step 5: Build Your ICP Document

Create a living document. Not a PDF you write once and forget.

Include:

• Company description and revenue range

• Primary and secondary decision-maker titles

• Key pain points and motivations

• Geographic and industry focus

• Deal size and contract terms

• Success metrics (close rate, meeting rate, average sales cycle length)

Review it quarterly. Update it when the market shifts or your product changes.

Step 6: Test and Validate

Here's the real test: does your team's outreach conversion rate increase when you're targeting the ICP, versus when they're not?

We measure this:

• Connection rate: Do ICPs pick up more often? (Benchmark: 8-15% for fintech cold calls)

• Meeting rate: Do ICP conversations convert to meetings? (Benchmark: 25-40% of conversations)

• Deal velocity: How long from first call to close? (Benchmark: 6-12 weeks for fintech outbound)

If your ICP is right, these numbers improve. If they don't, your ICP is wrong. Fix it.

---

How Nurturance Builds ICPs for Fintech Teams

This is the work we do for every client before we make a single call.

We audit your customer data, we interview your sales team, we run tests on small prospect lists, and we build an ICP that actually works. Then we run outbound through the Glencoco marketplace, connecting you with real calling teams who understand your space.

We get paid when we book meetings for you. That means we're as focused on the right ICP as you are.

If your team isn't seeing meetings from outreach, or your meetings aren't converting, let's audit your ICP. We usually spot the issue in the first call.

Ready to rebuild your outreach? Reach out to sales@nurturance.uk or book a call with the team.